Thank you for visiting our past auction result archives. If you have an item identical (or similar) to this auction lot, please call, write or contact us to discuss. We will be able to help you.

Lot # 113 (of 1389)   < Previous Lot | Next Lot >

1909-1911 E91A American Caramel Complete PSA-Graded Set (33)

Starting Bid - $500, Sold For - $3,600

Presented is a rarely seen set of all thirty-three Series A 1909-1911 E91 American Caramel Company cards, highlighted by twelve Hall of Famers. Issued by American Caramel over a period of three years, the E91 American Caramel Company set is classified as sets A, B, and C, with each series consisting of thirty-three cards featuring eleven players from each of three different teams. Each series is easily distinguishable by the reverse, which provides a checklist for the specific E91 subset. (The "A" series features Athletics, Cubs, and Giants.) The E91 set is sometimes referred to as the "fake design" set because the company used generic illustrations, rather than actual likenesses, of ballplayers. Thus, the exact same drawing (with team change on uniform) was used for two or three different players in the set. PSA Grading Composite: One EX-MT 6 (1 card): Davis. Four EX 5: Donlin (MC), Kling, Nicholls, and Slagle. One VG-EX+ 4.5: Bridwell. Five VG-EX 4: Devlin, Hartsel, McGinnity (HOF), McGraw (HOF), and Taylor. Four VG 3: Bender (HOF), Brown (HOF), Oldring, and Shulte. Seven GOOD 2: Evers (HOF), Murphy, Plank (HOF), Schreckengost, Seymour, Tenney, and Waddell (HOF). One FAIR 1.5: Scheckard. Six POOR 1: Collins (HOF, MK), Mathewson (HOF), Overall, Seybold, Steinfeldt, and Tinker (HOF). Four Authentic: Bresnahan (HOF), Chance (HOF), Reulbach, and Shay. The cards in the offered set, though in many cases technically modest in grade, present exceptionally well overall. Bold colors and crisp images throughout. This is a very attractive complete E91A set from one of the most interesting and distinctive of all caramel-card sets, highlighted by a dozen Hall of Famers. Total: 33 cards.

SOLD FOR $3,600


(Click the smaller thumbnails to the left and right (if any) to cycle through each photo in the gallery of images for this lot.)